Tom Deedy's Comment Wall

Tom Deedy's comment wall

Tom Deedy
Friday 2nd May 2008, 7:21am
Broken ankle parade. Kiwanuka, Ward, and Shockey. Who recovers and plays well? Does Kiwi move back to the DE position. In other words, does Strahan retire? I say no, he goes for the repeat.
Tom Deedy
Friday 2nd May 2008, 7:19am
Defense win games. Who starts at WLB? Danny Clark or Gerris Wilkinson? Both draft picks, B. Kehl, and J. Goff have the tackling ability, though Goff is more of an inside guy. Who starts at WLB?
Tom Deedy
Friday 2nd May 2008, 7:16am
Manningham or Moss? Terrell Thomas's injury history. Can Corey Webster repeat the playoff magic and sustain it for a full year? Plaxico Burress and Amani Toomer's age, wear and tear. Undersized MLB Pierce. Defending the center of the field. Inexperience at safety except for Butler who is slow footed and Sammy Knight who is really a linebacker playing back there -- without great coverage ability. These are the flashpoints I see. Anyone see others that are obstacles to a repeat? Coughlin reverts to the old Captain Ahab mentality is another one...
Tom Deedy
Friday 2nd May 2008, 7:11am
The Shockey Distraction. The Good and the Bad -- Talent is without question. Strong will. Immature sense of judgement which reflects a larger problem with this player. Despite the lengthly injury history that harms productivity on the field, Shockey, displays all the character traits a frustrated kid -- understandably -- look at his injury history. More revealing is his non-participation in the White House visit, the inability to come to spring practice with his team mates thus robbing the opportunity to build chemistry that is crucial in the passing game, and the constant misconception, promoted by the player, that he is the best competitor on the team. Well we won the whole shooting match last year without him. He's hurt all the time, hasn't finished a aseason in five years, drops the ball way too often, and is a marginal and unwilling blocker at best. I say the squeaky wheel gets the grease. Trade him for the best young big man, either on offense or defense, that we can get. New Orleans offer in the draft of a 2nd and 5th is close. Trade him into the AFC. Your thoughts, Jints fans? Trade Shockey or not?

This site is not affiliated, owned, or controlled or otherwise connected in any way to the New York Giants or the National Football League (NFL) or any of its entities.